Google+
  • Ocwen1.665+0.065 +4.062%
  • Zillow37.70-0.33 -0.87%
  • Trulia47+0 +0%
  • NationStar12.01-0.05 -0.41%
  • CoreLogic40.33-0.42 -1.03%
  • RE/MAX43.56+0.05 +0.11%
  • Fannie Mae1.9599-0.0101 -0.5127%
  • Freddie Mac1.762-0.008 -0.452%
  • Wells Fargo47.99-0.33 -0.68%
  • CitiMortgage44.01-0.29 -0.65%
  • Bank of America14.355-0.025 -0.174%
  • Fidelity National Financial38.19+0.04 +0.10%
  • First American42.10-0.34 -0.80%
  • AUDUSD=X0.7469+0.0014 +0.1864%
  • USDJPY=X105.7860-0.3630 -0.3420%
  • WP Stock Ticker
Home | Commentary | Counsel’s Corner: Borrowers Score a Victory in Wrongful Foreclosure Claim
Print This Post Print This Post

Counsel’s Corner: Borrowers Score a Victory in Wrongful Foreclosure Claim

Counsel's Corner
Eric Houser

Eric Houser

Eric Houser is the President of Houser & Allison, a firm that represents lenders and servicers in all 13 of the firm’s offices across the country from California to New York. Houser has been practicing law for 29 years and has a State and National litigation practice specializing in consumer and commercial finance, default servicing, title, bankruptcy, and technology litigation. Mr. Houser has extensive litigation experience in issues involving the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, Truth In Lending Act, Home Mortgage Disclosure Act, Fair Credit Reporting Act, and the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. He has tried cases from Maui, Hawaii to Litchfield, Connecticut, and many other places in between. He is a frequent public speaker. Houser & Allison is a member of the Legal League 100.

What are some of the more recent changes in the law that have impacted our industry?

Most recently in February 2016, the California Supreme Court came down with the long-awaited decision in the Yvanova v. New Century matter. This case has had notoriety because it is the first decision to reach the California Supreme Court which touches upon a borrower’s challenge to assignments of a loan (including securitization based claims) to support a wrongful foreclosure claim. The Court essentially concluded that a home loan borrower has standing to claim a nonjudicial foreclosure was wrongful because an assignment by which the foreclosing party purportedly took a beneficial interest in the deed of trust was not merely voidable but void, depriving the foreclosing party of any legitimate authority to order a trustee's sale. Borrowers' counsel are pleased with the decision which will most certainly increase litigation in California.

California has also expanded liability for servicers and lenders for tort damages (credit damage, possible emotional distress and punitive damages) in a wrongful foreclosure action and for servicing practices. In other words, Courts are tougher on our clients in California and best practices must always be used to prevent additional exposure.

The same goes for New York although in New York, the Courts have taken a different, less legalistic approach. The Courts have stalled the foreclosure process with multiple settlement conferences and long delays. New York has imposed more restrictions and requirements for lenders and servicers and has expanded liability for noncompliance, including the imposition of sanctions waiving interest for months or years if the court finds a lender did not negotiate in good faith in settlement conferences. The hot issue in New York continues to be the lender's standing to foreclose. The major hurdle in establishing standing is establishing possession of the note endorsed in blank at the time the action was commenced. Some courts have tried to expand this requirement by denying summary judgment unless the lender establishes the chain of custody for the entire history of the note including methods of delivery, dates of delivery and the identities of courier and recipient. Borrowers have also attempted to defeat standing to foreclose by arguing that the trustee did not receive possession of the note by the closing date set forth in the applicable pooling and servicing agreement (“PSA”) or by claiming that the assignment of mortgage is defective. Fortunately, the Appellate Division has effectively quashed any challenges to the PSA by definitively holding that borrowers do not have standing to challenge any alleged non-compliance. Ultimately, proof of possession at the time of commencement is the key to establishing standing.

Additional hot issues in New York relating to foreclosures are actions being dismissed for failure to establish compliance with RPAPL 1304 which mandates that a 90 day notice to be sent prior to foreclosure. The courts are now requiring that an affidavit of service be provided for this notice, which servicers were not doing. This has created a problem in cases where the statute of limitations has expired. Attorneys for lenders are making arguments to address the issue and so far the issue is unsettled.

What are the most challenging states at the moment?

Right now, New Mexico and Maine. The Courts in these states have, in my opinion, created barriers to enforcement of the mortgage, but have also created high exposure in terms of monetary damages. Clients must be very careful in all states at this time but in particular these two states.

About Author: Brian Honea

Brian Honea
Brian Honea's writing and editing career spans nearly two decades across many forms of media. He served as sports editor for two suburban newspaper chains in the DFW area and has freelanced for such publications as the Yahoo! Contributor Network, Dallas Home Improvement magazine, and the Dallas Morning News. He has written four non-fiction sports books, the latest of which, The Life of Coach Chuck Curtis, was published by the TCU Press in December 2014. A lifelong Texan, Brian received his master's degree from Amberton University in Garland.

121 comments

  1. Pingback: Counsel’s Corner: Borrowers Score a Victory in Wrongful Foreclosure Claim - Appraisal Buzz

  2. Pingback: Hawaii Foreclosure Auction | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  3. Pingback: Mortgage Notes Foreclosure | Selling Your House

  4. Pingback: Counsel’s Corner: Borrowers Score a Victory in Wrongful Foreclosure Claim - Brokers TitleBrokers Title

  5. Pingback: Foreclosure Procedures By State | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  6. Pingback: Homes Foreclosure In Ny | Homes For Sale Now

  7. Pingback: Country Home Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  8. Pingback: California Foreclosure Single Action Rule | Commercial Real Estate Listings

  9. Pingback: Hawaii Foreclosure Mortgage Companies | Homes For Sale Now

  10. Pingback: National Foreclosure Settlement News | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  11. Pingback: Mortgage Loan Foreclosure Credit | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  12. Pingback: Foreclosure Process In California 2010 | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  13. Pingback: Mortgage Lenders Foreclosure | Best Real Estate Agents

  14. Pingback: California Foreclosure Home | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  15. Pingback: How Long Between Preforeclosure And Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  16. Pingback: Long Between Default Foreclosure | Homes For Sale Now

  17. Pingback: Statute Of Limitations For Foreclosure In California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  18. Pingback: Ca Foreclosure Home In Visalia | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  19. Pingback: Commercial Foreclosure Procedures | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  20. Pingback: Foreclosure And Credit Report | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  21. Pingback: Home Loans Foreclosure Your Credit | Real Estate License Index

  22. Pingback: Home Foreclosure Procedures | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  23. Pingback: Foreclosure Homes New York | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  24. Pingback: Negotiating A Foreclosure Sale | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  25. Pingback: Is My Rental In Foreclosure California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  26. Pingback: Foreclosure Default Entered | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  27. Pingback: Foreclosure Notice Sale Trustee | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  28. Pingback: Foreclosure Lender Loan | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  29. Pingback: California Mortgage Foreclosure Consultant Act | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  30. Pingback: Foreclosed Homes New Mexico | Foreclosure Sales

  31. Pingback: Foreclosure Truth | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  32. Pingback: Inyc Foreclosure | Short Sale Houses

  33. Pingback: Foreclosure Trustee States | Find Houses For Sale

  34. Pingback: Foreclosure Lawsuit Settlement | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  35. Pingback: Is My House In Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  36. Pingback: How Long Is Foreclosure Process In New York | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  37. Pingback: Assignment Of Deed Of Trust Foreclosure | Foreclosure Short Sales

  38. Pingback: Foreclosed Homes In New | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  39. Pingback: Foreclosure On Credit Reports | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  40. Pingback: Home Foreclosure Credit Score | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  41. Pingback: Nys Foreclosure Process | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  42. Pingback: Foreclosure Publication California | Find Houses For Sale

  43. Pingback: Fcra Foreclosure Reporting | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  44. Pingback: Foreclosure On Credit | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  45. Pingback: Foreclosure Trustee Services California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  46. Pingback: Credit And Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  47. Pingback: Foreclosure Maine Laws | Homes For Sale Now

  48. Pingback: Foreclosure Homes Hawaii | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  49. Pingback: Foreclosure And Fdcpa | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  50. Pingback: Foreclosure Negotiations | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  51. Pingback: Commercial Property Foreclosure Laws In Texas | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  52. Pingback: Foreclosure Sales Hawaii | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  53. Pingback: New York Foreclosure Attorneys | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  54. Pingback: Foreclosure Homes Nrew York | Foreclosure Sales

  55. Pingback: Foreclosure Home Finance | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  56. Pingback: Ct Foreclosure House In | Find Houses For Sale

  57. Pingback: Foreclosure In California Law And Creditors | Best Real Estate Agents

  58. Pingback: Foreclosed Homes For Sale In New Mexico | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  59. Pingback: Foreclosure Laws California Bankruptcy | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  60. Pingback: Calif Foreclosure Process | Top Real Estate Listings

  61. Pingback: Foreclosure Multiple Lenders | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  62. Pingback: New York Foreclosure Law | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  63. Pingback: Foreclosure Order Of Dismissal | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  64. Pingback: Nonjudicial Foreclosure California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  65. Pingback: Foreclosure Homes Newmexico | Best Real Estate Agents

  66. Pingback: Notice Of Rescission California Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  67. Pingback: Maui Real Estate Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  68. Pingback: Commercial Foreclosure Process In New York | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  69. Pingback: New Law On Foreclosure In California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  70. Pingback: Foreclosure And Credit Scoring | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  71. Pingback: Wrongful Foreclosure Court Cases | Short Sale Houses

  72. Pingback: What Are Foreclosure Terms | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  73. Pingback: Wrongful Foreclosure California | Selling Your House

  74. Pingback: Foreclosure Summary Judgment | Foreclosure Info Sales

  75. Pingback: Home Foreclosure Process In Maine | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  76. Pingback: California Bankruptcy And Foreclosure Laws | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  77. Pingback: Mortgage Servicing Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  78. Pingback: Foreclosure Maui | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  79. Pingback: Foreclosure And Fico Score | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  80. Pingback: California Foreclosure Time Table | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  81. Pingback: Negotiating A Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  82. Pingback: Bankruptcy And Foreclosure In New York | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  83. Pingback: Unlawful Foreclosure Practices | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  84. Pingback: Credit Rating And Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  85. Pingback: Maui Foreclosure Homes | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  86. Pingback: Foreclosure Default Mortgage California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  87. Pingback: Maui Hi Foreclosure Homes | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  88. Pingback: What Is A Foreclosure Deed Of Trust | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  89. Pingback: Foreclosure Notice New York | Foreclosure Info Sales

  90. Pingback: A Wrongful Foreclosure | Find Houses For Sale

  91. Pingback: House Foreclosure Ny | Top Real Estate Listings

  92. Pingback: Hawaiian Foreclosure Sales | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  93. Pingback: New York Real Property Law Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  94. Pingback: Unlawful Foreclosure Lawsuit | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  95. Pingback: Assignment Deed Of Trust Foreclosure | Find Houses For Sale

  96. Pingback: Mandatory Foreclosure Settlement Conference New York | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  97. Pingback: Foreclosure Homes In New Mexico | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  98. Pingback: Wrongfull Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  99. Pingback: Punitive Damages For Wrongful Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  100. Pingback: Long Ca Foreclosure Process | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  101. Pingback: Hawaii Real Estate Foreclosure Law | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  102. Pingback: Commercial Foreclosure Process New York | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  103. Pingback: Length Of Foreclosure Process In California | Short Sale Houses

  104. Pingback: House Foreclosure Court Procedure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  105. Pingback: Ca Foreclosure Process | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  106. Pingback: Mortgage Foreclosure In Ct | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  107. Pingback: Foreclosure Attorney In Ny | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  108. Pingback: New Foreclosure Procedures | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  109. Pingback: Affidavit Of Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  110. Pingback: 90 Day Notice To Vacate California Foreclosure | Foreclosure Info Sales

  111. Pingback: Foreclosure Laws In Ca | Short Sale Houses

  112. Pingback: Hancock Maine Bankruptcy Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  113. Pingback: Foreclosure Property Maine | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  114. Pingback: Homes In Foreclosure In Connecticut | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  115. Pingback: Damages For Wrongful Foreclosure In Texas | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  116. Pingback: For Wrongful Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  117. Pingback: Of Wrongful Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  118. Pingback: Damages For Wrongful Foreclosure | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  119. Pingback: New Mexico Mortgage Fair Foreclosure Act | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  120. Pingback: Wrongful Foreclosure Damages California | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

  121. Pingback: California Wrongful Foreclosure Statute | Rates for CPA Services for SMB

Leave a Reply

Scroll To Top