Google+
  • Ocwen3.15+0.05 +1.61%
  • Zillow39.92-0.36 -0.89%
  • Trulia47+0 +0%
  • NationStar17.70+0.38 +2.19%
  • CoreLogic45.65-0.36 -0.78%
  • RE/MAX61.55+0.85 +1.40%
  • Fannie Mae2.80+0.06 +2.19%
  • Freddie Mac2.645+0.045 +1.731%
  • Wells Fargo54.06+0.31 +0.58%
  • CitiMortgage71.76+0.30 +0.42%
  • Bank of America25.16+0.10 +0.40%
  • Fidelity National Financial47.39-0.91 -1.88%
  • First American48.84-0.42 -0.85%
  • Black Knight Financial Services43.45-0.55 -1.25%
  • AUDUSD=X0.7930-0.0002 -0.0202%
  • USDJPY=X111.9500-0.4660 -0.4145%
Home | Uncategorized | New HUD Guidance on Use of Criminal Background Checks
Print This Post Print This Post

New HUD Guidance on Use of Criminal Background Checks

white-collar-crime-twoOn April 4, 2016, HUD’s General Counsel released guidance for all housing providers (not just those who are HUD subsidized) regarding how the use of criminal background checks could potentially violate fair housing laws. If you are a Landlord and run criminal background checks as part of your screening process, it is important for you to become familiar with the guidance. Although this is HUD guidance, rather than law, it clearly outlines how HUD would analyze a fair housing complaint based on the use of criminal background checks to deny housing.

The guidance focuses on “disparate impact” (discriminatory effect) discrimination. Disparate impact occurs when a landlord has a policy or practice that is neutral (i.e., non-discriminatory) on its face and applies equally to all applicants and/or residents, but its application has a discriminatory effect on one or more of the protected classes. In order to successfully defend a claim of discrimination, the landlord must be able to show that this policy or practice is necessary in order to achieve a non-discriminatory business objective, and that there is no less discriminatory alternative that would achieve that business objective.

The HUD guidance states that due to the higher than average incarceration rates among certain races (Hispanics and African Americans) in the United States relative to their percentage of the total population and when compared against the incarceration rates of non-Hispanic Caucasians, the use of criminal history to deny housing can cause a disparate impact on these particular races. Therefore, if Landlords want to use criminal background checks as part of their rental criteria, they have the burden to show: (1) it is necessary to use criminal background checks in order to achieve a non-discriminatory business objective and; (2) there is no less discriminatory alternative. (The “business objective” would presumably be the protection of resident safety and/or property. However, the guidance states that the business objective cannot be prospective in nature. The landlord must prove that the use of the criminal background checks actually accomplishes the business objective.)

The HUD memo goes on to state that in order to meet this burden when a Landlord’s policy has a disparate impact, Landlords must consider the following:

  • Arrest Records: HUD states that landlords should not use arrest records as a basis for excluding applicants. According to HUD’s General Counsel, an arrest which does not lead to a subsequent conviction does not prove that an individual engaged in illegal activity. Therefore, the use of arrest records would not provide information regarding whether the applicant who was arrested would be a threat to the safety of other residents or their property.
  • Prior Convictions: Although prior convictions are sufficient evidence to prove that an individual engaged in criminal conduct, HUD’s General Counsel states: “A housing provider that imposes a blanket prohibition on any person with any conviction record- no matter when the conviction occurred, what the underlying conduct entailed, or what the convicted person has done since then- will be unable to meet this burden.”

In other words, according to HUD’s General Counsel, if a landlord is going to use criminal records as part of the screening criteria, the policy must be narrowly tailored. The guidance goes on to state that even then a landlord would still need to prove that this “tailored” policy is necessary to serve a “substantial, legitimate, nondiscriminatory interest.” In order to do this, a landlord must be able to show that its “tailored” use of criminal background checks “accurately distinguishes between criminal conduct that indicates a demonstrable risk to resident safety and/or property and criminal conduct that does not.”

So what does this all mean? Can Landlords take into account the criminal background of applicants as part of their screening criteria without violating fair housing laws? This latest HUD guidance does confirm that there is one “safe harbor” available to landlords: If a landlord uses criminal background checks and only excludes applicants who have been convicted of the illegal manufacture or distribution of a controlled substance, a landlord will not run afoul of fair housing laws. This is because the Fair Housing Act specifically states that landlords do not have to make housing available to persons with such a conviction. The guidance warns, however, that the exclusion is only for manufacture or distribution (making or selling) controlled substances and does not extend to other drug-related crimes such as use or possession.

What if a landlord wants to exclude applicants who have been convicted of other crimes? Will it be considered a fair housing violation? Other than the safe harbor addressed above, the HUD memo does not specify what types of criminal convictions would warrant a denial to rent. However, the HUD guidance does provide some general guidelines which landlords must consider if they choose to go beyond denial of applicants convicted of illegal manufacture or distribution of controlled substances:

  • Nature of the Conviction: The guidance states that a landlord who wants to use criminal background checks must take into account the “nature and severity” of an individual’s conviction. For example, the landlord should consider the exact crime and how severe it was. Moreover, the landlord should consider whether the fact that the applicant engaged in this particular type of criminal activity means this applicant will be a greater risk to resident safety and/or property. This closer scrutiny that HUD is requiring means that landlords should avoid blanket restrictions such as a policy that excludes all applicants who have any felony conviction.
  • When the Criminal Activity Occurred: The guidance also states that a landlord who screens for criminal history must take into account how long ago the criminal activity occurred. According to HUD’s general counsel, there is “criminological research” which shows that over time, “the likelihood that a person with a prior criminal record will engage in additional criminal conduct decreases until it approximates the likelihood that a person with no criminal history will commit an offense.” In other words, crimes that occurred a long time ago should be considered less relevant as compared to more recent crimes (and possibly not considered at all). So how far back should a landlord look? Could a landlord safely consider a crime that took place 5 years ago? 10 years ago? Unfortunately HUD offers no guidance on this question. It is left up to the landlord to be able to defend whatever policy they choose to implement.
  • Individualized Assessment: The HUD memo goes on to state that not only do Landlords need to narrowly tailor their use of an applicant’s criminal history, but they must also show that this narrowly tailored policy has the least possible discriminatory affect. In order to accomplish this goal, HUD recommends that Landlords conduct an “individualized assessment” of each applicant, considering “relevant mitigating information” such as; (1) the facts or circumstances surrounding the criminal conduct; (2) the age of the individual at the time the conduct occurred; (3) evidence that the individual has maintained a good tenant history before and after the conviction or conduct; (4) and evidence of rehabilitation efforts.

Finally, the guidance states even if a Landlord’s use of criminal background checks is narrowly tailored by taking into consideration the nature and severity of the crime, the length of time since conviction occurred, and where individualized assessments are carried out, a Landlord “will still bear the burden of proving that any discriminatory effect caused by such policy or practice [involving the use of criminal background checks] is justified.

Based on this guidance from HUD, the only sure way a Landlord can avoid fair housing liability if he/she wants to consider an applicant’s criminal history is to limit the policy to exclude only applicants with prior convictions for illegal manufacture or distribution of controlled substances.[1] If a landlord wants to deny an applicant for any other convictions, the landlord must be able to prove that the particular policy is necessary in order to achieve a substantial, legitimate, non-discriminatory interest, and that there is no less discriminatory way to achieve this interest.

Our Fair Housing Practice Group has a detailed opinion letter on criminal background checks. Please contact us today at (800) 338-6039 for more information or to purchase this opinion letter.

[1] Note that project-based HUD subsidized properties must also prohibit admission to sex offenders subject to a lifetime registration requirement under state government’s sex offender registration program or to individuals found to have manufactured or produced methamphetamine on the premises of federally assisted housing.

Profile photo
Kimball, Tirey and St. John LLP is a full service real estate law firm representing residential and commercial property owners and managers. This alert is for general information purposes only. Laws may have changed since this article was published. Before acting, be sure to receive legal advice from our office. If you have questions, please contact your local KTS office. For contact information, please visit our website: www.kts-law.com. For past Legal Alerts, Questions & Answers and Legal Articles, please consult the resource library section of our website.

216 comments

  1. Pingback: New HUD Guidance on Use of Criminal Background Checks - Appraisal Buzz

  2. Pingback: New HUD Guidance on Use of Criminal Background Checks - Brokers TitleBrokers Title

  3. Pingback: Ruksis780

  4. Pingback: xmt85c4wx5ctwxw3tcerthve56

  5. Pingback: http://falschgeldkaufen.blogspot.com/2017/01/wo-kann-ich-falschgeld-kaufen.html

  6. Pingback: treatments for alcoholism

  7. Pingback: دانلود قسمت هشتم شهرزاد دوم

  8. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت هشتم فصل دوم

  9. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت دوازدهم فصل دوم

  10. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت هفتم فصل دوم

  11. Pingback: قیمت پنجره

  12. Pingback: XXX

  13. Pingback: دانلود قسمت 10 شهرزاد دوم

  14. Pingback: دانلود قسمت ششم فصل دوم شهرزاد

  15. Pingback: دانلود قسمت دوازدهم عاشقانه

  16. Pingback: دانلود قسمت هفدهم عاشقانه

  17. Pingback: Elena Koshka

  18. Pingback: Kiera Rose

  19. Pingback: Christy Mack

  20. Pingback: دانلود فصل دوم شهرزاد

  21. Pingback: hampton bay ceiling fan blog

  22. Pingback: دانلود قسمت هفتم فصل دوم شهرزاد

  23. Pingback: Free Stuff Worldwide

  24. Pingback: lesbian porn

  25. Pingback: slot machine casino

  26. Pingback: Boom lift repair florida

  27. Pingback: پنجره

  28. Pingback: دانلود سریال عاشقانه

  29. Pingback: Hundeskove i Danmark

  30. Pingback: دانلود قسمت پنجم شهرزاد دوم

  31. Pingback: bypass windows 7 administrator password

  32. Pingback: under armour melbourne

  33. Pingback: porno gratis

  34. Pingback: taylormade m2 driver australia

  35. Pingback: porno gratis

  36. Pingback: videos porno

  37. Pingback: porno gratis

  38. Pingback: videos porno

  39. Pingback: porno gratis

  40. Pingback: videos porno

  41. Pingback: videos porno

  42. Pingback: sagittarius female leo male love compatibility

  43. Pingback: قیمت پنجره دوجداره

  44. Pingback: آموزش ساخت پنجره دوجداره

  45. Pingback: دانلود فیلم سریال عاشقانه

  46. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره ویستابست

  47. Pingback: فروش پنجره دو سه جداره

  48. Pingback: پنجره ضد سرقت ایرانی ترک المانی

  49. Pingback: دانلود قسمت 17 عاشقانه

  50. Pingback: CBD Pills For Sale

  51. Pingback: Facial Spa Services Cooper City

  52. Pingback: Facial Spa Services Lauderdale Lakes

  53. Pingback: دانلود موزیک

  54. Pingback: پنجره

  55. Pingback: hip support

  56. Pingback: فروش توری پنجره دوجداره

  57. Pingback: دانلود قسمت ششم شهرزاد

  58. Pingback: bitch

  59. Pingback: Roof Repair Long Island

  60. Pingback: cheap hotel booking

  61. Pingback: clic here

  62. Pingback: video gaming

  63. Pingback: unlimited clash royale gems

  64. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  65. Pingback: پنجره دو سه جداره

  66. Pingback: i88Cash

  67. Pingback: sale LED Recessed lights

  68. Pingback: coin-banks

  69. Pingback: coin-banks

  70. Pingback: magazin de pescuit

  71. Pingback: DraftKings DFS

  72. Pingback: coin-banks bitcoin

  73. Pingback: tenzi q7

  74. Pingback: cliquez ici

  75. Pingback: nicocontrol pre�o

  76. Pingback: دانلود قسمت هشتم شهرزاد دوم

  77. Pingback: mdansby software

  78. Pingback: vpm

  79. Pingback: anime series

  80. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد 13

  81. Pingback: دانلود سریال شهرزاد قسمت 15 پانزده

  82. Pingback: دانلود سریال شهرزاد قسمت 15

  83. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت سیزده 13

  84. Pingback: zobacz

  85. Pingback: http://jarrowlife.co.uk/User-meditus1

  86. Pingback: Social Media Marketing

  87. Pingback: http://jiechuhui.com/upload/home.php?mod=space&uid=372562&do=profile&from=space

  88. Pingback: Supercars

  89. Pingback: key

  90. Pingback: right here

  91. Pingback: video for kids

  92. Pingback: 16 دانلود سریال شهرزاد

  93. Pingback: Roof Repair Long Island

  94. Pingback: Yoshie

  95. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت 16

  96. Pingback: دانلود فیلم ایرانی

  97. Pingback: 火锅

  98. Pingback: دانلود عالیجناب اول 1

  99. Pingback: دانلود عالیجناب قسمت اول

  100. Pingback: Learn Colors

  101. Pingback: Best Crib Mattress

  102. Pingback: car repair and maintenance

  103. Pingback: game

  104. Pingback: Cartoon Comedy

  105. Pingback: پنجره ضد سرقت المانی

  106. Pingback: collection

  107. Pingback: قیمت پنجره دوجداره

  108. Pingback: آموزش پنجره دوجداره

  109. Pingback: دانلود

  110. Pingback: شرکت تولیدی پنجره دوجداره ترک

  111. Pingback: small business ideas

  112. Pingback: g30 australia

  113. Pingback: Upholstery Cleaning nolanville TX

  114. Pingback: nursery rhymes

  115. Pingback: free shipping

  116. Pingback: Vancouver Limo Services

  117. Pingback: ici

  118. Pingback: rent home

  119. Pingback: emoji

  120. Pingback: aws training

  121. Pingback: sell home

  122. Pingback: دانلود فیلم سریال ایرانی

  123. Pingback: marketing network

  124. Pingback: Digital Advertising UK

  125. Pingback: Double chambered

  126. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  127. Pingback: gummy bear

  128. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  129. Pingback: finger family

  130. Pingback: Web Design Fort Worth

  131. Pingback: ключар

  132. Pingback: kids songs

  133. Pingback: دانلود

  134. Pingback: پنجره

  135. Pingback: پنجره

  136. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  137. Pingback: Custom Assignment Services

  138. Pingback: شرکت تولیدی پنجره دوجداره

  139. Pingback: اموزش ساخت پنجره دوجداره

  140. Pingback: فروش توری پنجره دوجداره

  141. Pingback: websites to buy weed online

  142. Pingback: IELTS test in Karachi

  143. Pingback: SEO Manchester

  144. Pingback: viagra

  145. Pingback: instagram porn

  146. Pingback: مشاوره بازاریابی اینترنتی

  147. Pingback: endtimes signs 2017

  148. Pingback: garden bridges san francisco

  149. Pingback: agen99

  150. Pingback: telak 4d online

  151. Pingback: walmartone login

  152. Pingback: cars

  153. Pingback: Vancouver BC

  154. Pingback: web link

  155. Pingback: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bld2NoB1hBI

  156. Pingback: https://en.gravatar.com/adulttoys195

  157. Pingback: lifestyle

  158. Pingback: Gratis Report

  159. Pingback: edsheeran

  160. Pingback: buy proxy

  161. Pingback: فیلم اکسیدان

  162. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  163. Pingback: iron stair parts

  164. Pingback: Learn English with Songs

  165. Pingback: Bad Spiderman

  166. Pingback: Website

  167. Pingback: (apple reseller program)

  168. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  169. Pingback: پنجره

  170. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  171. Pingback: قیمت پنجره

  172. Pingback: Nursery Rhymes

  173. Pingback: Seo Yakima

  174. Pingback: zobacz

  175. Pingback: Web Design

  176. Pingback: Autumn

  177. Pingback: garden

  178. Pingback: Learn Colors for Kids

  179. Pingback: usi tech

  180. Pingback: Online Casino Malaysia

  181. Pingback: future ad pro scam

  182. Pingback: how to vlog

  183. Pingback: disconnected undercut http://haircutinspiration.com/disconnected-undercut/

  184. Pingback: maintenance

  185. Pingback: nikon d5300 price manual

  186. Pingback: Fuzjn Project 365

  187. Pingback: Fuzjn 365

  188. Pingback: Fuzjn 365

  189. Pingback: gay porn

  190. Pingback: Seo

  191. Pingback: chips bowl

  192. Pingback: 12 month loans bad credit

  193. Pingback: دانلود

  194. Pingback: Türnotöffnung

  195. Pingback: Solutions Manual

  196. Pingback: Solutions Manual

  197. Pingback: download movie

  198. Pingback: دانلود

  199. Pingback: دانلود سریال

  200. Pingback: window

  201. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  202. Pingback: garden bridges

  203. Pingback: garden bridges San Jose

  204. Pingback: seo company jacksonville

  205. Pingback: Bad Credit Remortgages

  206. Pingback: Samantha

  207. Pingback: More here

  208. Pingback: blocks

  209. Pingback: Self Storage Units and Facilities in New Rochelle

  210. Pingback: watch it movie streaming

  211. Pingback: Judi Bola

  212. Pingback: kids animation

  213. Pingback: recruitment consultancy

  214. Pingback: breast augmentation in Houston

  215. Pingback: 10 Facts About USA Military

  216. Pingback: Mac Screen Service and Repair

Leave a Reply

Scroll To Top